Same-Sex Marriage Advocates Withdraw the Last of Eight Cases Filed in Florida

Dec 4, 2006

March 27, 2006

Orlando, FL - Same-sex marriage advocates have now dismissed all eight lawsuits filed in Florida challenging Florida's marriage laws. Attorneys who brought the case of Higgs v. Kolhage in Key West, Florida, filed papers on February 13, 2006, requesting dismissal. The plaintiffs in Higgs are represented by the National Center for Lesbian Rights (NCLR). Liberty Counsel filed an amicus brief in support of Florida's marriage laws in this case.

The same attorney with the NCLR who represents Higgs is also a member of the legal team which argued against allowing Florida voters to have the opportunity to pass an amendment to the Florida Constitution to protect marriage as the union of one man and one woman. On February 8, 2006 - the week before the NCLR filed for dismissal of the Higgs case - the Florida Supreme Court heard oral argument on the amendment. Mathew D. Staver, president and general counsel of Liberty Counsel, argued for the amendment, and the NCLR attorney was also present. The argument did not go well for the NCLR and the ACLU, as the justices appeared skeptical of the arguments against the amendment. Indeed, the Court issued a unanimous opinion last week upholding the amendment language. NCLR must have realized that the Higgs case would fare no better before the Court than their opposition to the marriage amendment.

Five other cases that were filed in state court, but were dismissed last year, include: Ash v. Forman (Broward County); Clayton v. Ake (Hillsboro County); Merritt v. Gardner (Orange County); Berman v. Wilkin (Palm Beach County); and Kelley v. Green (Lee County). The dismissal of these cases followed on the heels of a federal court decision in the Florida case of Wilson v. Ake, which upheld Florida's marriage laws in January 2005. The Wilson case rejected an attempt to extend a Massachusetts same-sex marriage to Florida. The other federal court case dismissed last year was Sullivan v. Bush (Southern District of Florida).

Mathew D. Staver commented: "Although all eight court challenges against Florida's marriage laws are over, voters can only be certain to protect marriage through the passage of a state constitutional amendment. To successfully defend marriage, we must win all of the time. One loss can create a ripple effect around the country. Courts did not create marriage and should not destroy it. Efforts to pass state and federal constitutional marriage amendments will continue to move forward. When people are allowed a choice, they always choose marriage as the union of only one man and one woman."

A large coalition of Florida groups is promoting a citizen initiative to pass a state constitutional amendment. The proposed amendment, for which a statewide vote is planned in 2008, states: "Inasmuch as marriage is the legal union of only one man and one woman as husband and wife, no other legal union that is treated as marriage or the substantial equivalent thereof shall be valid or recognized." The petition for the amendment is accessible online at www.LC.org and www.Florida4Marriage.org.

Event Update

Over the weekend, Anita and I attended an event in St Petersburg, Florida, to support the ministry of Child Evangelism Fellowship. CEF is engaged in many vital outreaches for children all over the world, including Good News Clubs. For many years, Liberty Counsel has been helping CEF gain equal access to public school facilities so that children can attend Good News Clubs immediately after school. Good News Clubs teach morals from a Christian viewpoint and help lead children to Christ. We are truly blessed to partner with CEF and to encourage others to support and pray for that important ministry so that every public school in America can have a Good News Club. For more information, contact us today.

Today I am in Washington, D.C. for a conference sponsored by Vision America. I will join a panel discussion this afternoon entitled, "The ACLU and Radical Secularism: Driving God from our Public Life." We deeply appreciate your prayers and support.

Sponsorship Opportunity

We are looking for monthly sponsors for April and May, so that we can continue to fund these Liberty Alert emails to keep you informed about your religious freedom, the sanctity of human life and the traditional family. Please contact us for more information.

We Are Grateful for our Friends ...

Christian Financial Principles

"invest for your goals, invest with your values"

A nationwide investment firm committed to providing products and services not only superior in strength and performance, but also embracing Christian values. You may have God's money invested in companies involved with abortion, pornography, or homosexual lifestyles without even knowing it! For a free Christian values report of your present investment portfolio, visit www.christianfp.com or call (877) 723-6975.

Make a tax-deductible online donation to this ministry

TAKE ACTION